Pages

Tuesday, 12 March 2013

What is weakness, anyway? A guest-post from Dr Gerry Ramogida



What would you do in this situation?

It becomes evident (either through muscle testing or observation) that a muscle is not ‘firing’ as well as it should be.  A typical scenario that we often find is that the ‘gluts have shut off’.  Or the TVA.  Or - my favorite in the UK - the soleus.  

Easy question, right?  You strengthen it...

Well - it’s not that simple.  The answer to this question has actually become quite a contentious issue over the last few years - especially with the recent popularization of ‘corrective exercise specialists’.  Gray Cook popularized the term ‘don’t add strength to dysfunction’. And while I can’t say that I disagree with this statement, I definitely have issues with the ways in which many therapists eliminate this so-called ‘dysfunction’.  

By the way, Mike Young briefly discussed this concept on his blog at Elitetrack.com back in August of 2012, and I couldn’t agree more with his thoughts.  


Our chiropractor, and lead performance therapist, in the UK for the last three years has been the excellent Dr Gerry Ramogida.  We were extremely lucky to have him, and I can state for a fact that one of the gold medals on Super Saturday’ would not have been won had it not been for Gerry’s tireless work.  

Over the last few years, he (along with Andy Burke, our other performance therapist - also highly skilled) has taken specific interest in the role of fascia in human movement, and specifically how it affects optimal mechanics.  

I have asked him to share some of his thoughts on this topic, and though the following may be a little technical for some, I urge you to be patient and work through it, as I feel it is key to understanding function.



What is weakness, anyway?  
A guest-post from Dr Gerry Ramogida

When I was working in the UK with Stu, Dan Pfaff, Andy Burke, and the rest of the crew we often had debates about the need for specific strengthening in areas, or directly to tissues that were injured or that appeared to be not functioning well when observing an athletes movement.  The ‘need to strengthen’ debate was one which at times was heated.  When I arrived in the UK, I was on the fence.  Of course an area which was ‘weak’ needed some direct strengthening.  I could convince myself of this, and in fact there are times where we do need to develop strategies designed to strengthen a particular muscle group. However, what I found quite frequently was that we could make very quick changes in muscle behavior and contractile abilities with hands on work, combined with motor re-education in the form of repeated, progressive technical exercises and drills.  Part of what happened was that in our efforts to learn, we became more efficient and effective with our hands-on work, enabling us to be much more accurate anatomically with our manual techniques.  Dr. Guy Voyer’s fascial fellowship helped immensely in this regard, giving both Andy Burke and myself new-found appreciation for the interrelationship of many structures, linked structurally and functionally directly via the fascia.  My observations over time spawned what I present here - an argument that observed weakness is often not weakness in the traditional sense but a manifestation of myofascial structural change which reduces afferent input into the complex neural symphony which is responsible for the output of muscular contraction.  


What is Weakness?

When identifying movement dysfunction, we often draw the conclusion that there is 'weakness' - that a particular muscle group or chain of synergists is not 'strong' enough. We often make this conclusion without really giving thought to all that determines coordinated output of force.  

When we look at muscle structure we now know that both the contractile (extrafusal fibers) and non-contractile elements (intrafusal fibers) insert, not directly to the tendons, but to the fascial layers (endomysium, perimysium, and epimysium) at points throughout the length of a muscle.  It is these layers which then come together to form the tendon structure inserting into the bone (and continuing directly into the periosteum). It would therefore be safe to say that muscles do not insert into bone, but into fascia, which then coalesces to insert onto bone.  

"Muscle is just a stupid piece of meat."  - Dr. Guy Voyer

To the extent that the contractile elements on their own are completely dependent on fascia to be functional, Dr Voyer is absolutely correct.  




We also know that 40% of myofascial tissue does not insert into the musculo-tendonus junction/tendon or bone, but rather into other fascial layers of surrounding agonist, synergist, and antagonist muscles/myofascial tissues (epimyseum, inter-muscular septa, retinaculum, etc.).  For what purpose would evolution produce and maintain connection between various muscle groups and other soft tissues via fascial sheets of collagen matrix (richly innervated by various afferent/sensory receptors) if function (strength/power) was determined only by the muscles functional cross sectional area? (which is what we are saying when observed or identified weakness is only addressed via strengthening exercises)  

Why would the sensory units (muscle spindles and golgi tendon organs) which determine muscle tone and sensitivity to stretch insert into the fascia if the fascia were not a critical link both mechanically and proprioceptively?  

Ultimately, if the fascial layers do not move freely then the sensory units inserting into these layers, providing the brain and spinal cord constant feedback regarding movement quantity and quality is compromised/diminished, or incomplete. This degradation of afferent feedback (aka proprioception) ultimately results in decreased motor pool activation at the spinal cord level.  When we cannot optimally recruit available motor units within a given muscle, would we not observe weakness?  In many cases “weakness" occurs not because there is a lack of cross sectional area, but results from a loss of afferent-efferent feedback necessary for optimal muscular contraction.  

Conceptually, this can also influence strength of contraction through functional fascial chains. Through the research findings of the Stecco Family and Dr Jaap van der Wal, we understand that the continuous fascial chains spanning long areas of the body linking many muscle groups are not conceptual constructs but true anatomical links.  Given this anatomical continuity we can imagine a situation where ineffective muscular contraction at one link in a synergistic chain reduces the tension passed via these fascial links into the subsequent members.  This decreases stimulus through reduced fascial pretension to the agoninst/synergist/antagonist muscle spindles, leading directly to decreased motor unit activation/strength of contraction in the remainder of the chain. Such diminishment of communication between links will then potentially alter the firing sequence and timing of contraction - resulting in further displays of 'weakness'.  



In short, fascial lack of compliance and mobility leads to diminished afferent feedback reducing motor pool activation and alters firing patterns (fascial chain contraction sequencing).  With poor contraction quality and sequencing, the resulting apparent 'weakness' can lead to changes in the instantaneous centre of movement of related joints.  When a joint’s centre of rotation (or motion) is at a point off of its anatomically  correct position, we observe aberrant arthrokinematics.  Altered joint mechanics leads to the bearing of load in areas not designed to bear such stresses, and efficient movement is compromised.  Increased loading stress is passed into the supportive tissues (joint capsules, ligaments, retinaculum, all the same myofascial structures mentioned previously.  This repetitive strain contributes to altered tissue tone and structural change, and the vicious cycle worsens slowly over time.  

As joint motion is compromised, intra-articular swelling and irregular wear can result. This leads to arthrogenic inhibition where joint mechanoreceptor feedback is lost in much the same manner as in the myofascia.  This leads to further inhibition of musculature spanning the involved joint, and additionally adding to 'weakness'.  This process will potentially be a driver in degenerative processes such as tendinosis (itis), osteoarthritis, etc..



I apologize for the wordy journey I have taken you on here.  I hope it has raised some thoughts in your mind and may lead you to look at the potential causes for observed weakness.  

The question one should always ask when they observe 'weakness' is why?  

Is there an inadequate production of force for the observed activity because the cross sectional area of the muscle is not sufficient? 

Is there neurologic compromise? 

Is there vascular compromise? 

Is there poor interaction with its agonists or antagonists?

Is there associated joint misalignment?  

If any of these other than the first are present then the best strengthening exercises will be of little benefit.  Injury recurrence is highly likely when the underlying cause is not elucidated.  In my experience one should evaluate tissue quality of all the potentially related soft tissues in the associated area of observed weakness.  

Has previous injury and the resultant inflammatory cycle led to fibrotic change in critical areas influencing the sensory organs?  

Has this led to poor firing sequences?  

Has alteration in tissues led to a change in joint mechanics?  

Most elite athletes come with long injury histories.  In the absence of good hands-on treatment and rehab, it is often very likely that tissue changes are playing a role in observed weakness.



Gerry was an integral part of the UK Athletics success over the last three years, while also helping Bolton Wanderers and Wales defender Sam Ricketts return to the field of play after achilles surgery.  He is a highly-sought after speaker and consultant, and has now returned to North America with his family, where he consults with the Seattle Seahawks.  He can be reached on Twitter at @DrGerryRamogida

52 comments:

  1. I think nothing to discuss about, this time. Spot on!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Our small business has been serving the making us the most reliable fencing company in all of Edmonton.commercial fencing edmonton

      Delete
  2. Very interesting article, thanks Stu. As a coach you want to know more - the follow up to this is what interventions can be taken to manage these issues.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks Aston ... that's the big question! How do we now as coaches use this information to affect our practices. Gerry and I will be writing on this on a future post (if I can talk him into it!)

      Delete
  3. Think having a dominant side has a lot to do with it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was great, tremendous read. Always learning through your efforts doc!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I?d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I?ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing. Appoint Best Surgeon for Knee Injury doctor in Lahore and recover your injuries fast with drwajid best surgeon for sport injuries.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information? dewa poker

    ReplyDelete
  7. This was a really nice post. In bancatien idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem cuoc bong 88 to get something done.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello! I think these information Will be helpful for you.

    novotisinjusticia.com
    friendsofbcfc.com
    Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  9. These are the articles I need.Your article is very good. I love reading your blog. Thank you for sharing.KỸ NĂNG SỐNG|KỸ NĂNG GIAO TIẾP|LÀM VIỆC THEO NHÓM|LÃNH ĐẠO|QUẢN LÝ THỜI GIAN

    ReplyDelete
  10. Your content is really good. Thanks for sharing
    open-sft
    cchfulton

    ReplyDelete
  11. I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing. theplaynews.com/

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for the blog post buddy! Keep them coming... The play news

    ReplyDelete
  13. At times Epson printer user may experience the issue Epson Printer Not Printing during a print work. This is the most well-known printing error looked by user. The error may upset the user work, in such a condition, the client gets defenseless. Epson printer is not printing

    ReplyDelete
  14. Printing from PC is the most well-known interaction particularly in an office setting. Along these lines, when the printing machine startlingly rejects to print, a progression of postponements and activity issues emerge. Here are some viable strategies, you can do when your Brother printer not printing from PC. Also, you can take total direction from Brother Printer Help group. Confirmed Printer experts have great information to comprehend genuine reasons for this specialized malfunction.There are numerous reasons why a brother printer doesn't print. It contains insufficient toner levels, paper sticking, worn outs, or inside jams or obsolete printer drivers.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very helpful information specifically the final phase. I handle such info a lot. I used to be seeking this certain info for a long time. 토토

    ReplyDelete
  16. Excellent post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I’m inspired! 온라인카지노

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is a really very informative article, there is no doubt about it. Thanks for sharing this article with us. This is very nice of you. 온라인경마

    ReplyDelete
  18. I love reading through and I believe this website got some genuinely 토토

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for sharing this article i really appreciate you for this keep it up do you want discounted coupon then you are at right comment check this out ffxi copper voucher

    ReplyDelete
  20. Wow such an amazing content keep it up looking forward for more on this website check this out Women Two Toned Jacket available in special discount and with free shipping as well

    ReplyDelete
  21. The wireless printer setup is one of the core components of business exercises at working environments. Doing it in the ideal way guarantees the accessibility of your printing machine for true purposes and when you feel the requirement for it. Connect brother dcp-t710w printer Peruse the article underneath to see every one of the necessary strides to interface Brother printer to wifi.When it comes to "How to Connect Brother Printer to WiFi?" alongside setting up the design of your Brother printer, it is essential to adhere to the legitimate principles and steps for a continuous exhibition. Thus, read underneath the article exhaustively and discover every one of the means you need to follow if your sibling printer not associating with wifi.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks for sharing this amazing post. So if you are interested in trading and earning money online I recommend you to trade with Traders Central that is the best forex trading platform and is the world’s first subscription-based and one time fee funding platform for forex retail traders.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Searching for help on How to arrange brother MFCL2750DW remote printer with Wifi? Try not to stress we are here to direct you to interface brother printer wifi setup network association between your printer. Brother printer MFC L2750dw wireless setup You can run over different issues while using a computer, it's totally fine. My group will be taking care of everything. Try not to stress over this we'll help you. It is needed to design sibling MFCL2750DW remote printer with Wifi in light of the fact that without web association, you can't introduce the printer driver. What's more, you can't print without getting a printer driver in your machine. In this way, simply take Brother Printer AID in the event that you Don't realize how to add Brother Printer to Wifi to interface Wifi between your Brother Printer and your machine.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck. dofollow blog comment

    ReplyDelete
  25. You may ask for countless maids as you must get the home organized plus keep them clean. With the following services you will get an a lot easier life by using one a reduced amount of thing to keep worrying about. You will customize a person's cleaning wants and agenda cleaning as often as you require. The greatest things about this company are lots of, but a vey important advantage is definitely time discounts. house cleaning services dubai

    ReplyDelete
  26. Update Latest Video Real-Time
    We have a lot of hard-to-get videos.
    High-definition elderly! All available free of charge.
    My wife is having a fling with another guy at home.
    All domestic, Japanese, and even American.
    일본야동

    ReplyDelete
  27. Holds largest export volume in Korea!
    Latest Real-Time Updates!
    A class of faith and trust in a 15-year business!
    The quality is the best quality! The price is the lowest price!
    1:1 Counsellor, please wait 24 hours!
    레플리카

    ReplyDelete
  28. Three inspections before delivery.
    Full refund in case of a problem!
    Cost-effectiveness up! Price down!
    Take a photo of the actual product!
    Check! Update every day!
    홍콩명품

    ReplyDelete
  29. Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck => ty le bong da hom nay hap dan tu nha cai uy tin FB88

    ReplyDelete
  30. Our men red white rib jacket is tighter-fitting, and less insulating than a coat, which is one of our best products only available at topcelebsjackets.com.

    ReplyDelete
  31. تعمیر یخچال و فریزر در مرکز حرفه ای دو سوت تعمیر

    دسته تعمیرات یخچال

    ReplyDelete
  32. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  33. One of the most important maintenance services for your car, truck or SUV is none other than the oil and filter change. Scheduled maintenance will keep your car running smoothly for years, and it can evencar Air filter replacement Abu Dhabi help increase the value if you ever decide to sell your car. ALSA Automotive Repair is pleased to assist you with a complete oil change, lube and filter service.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Compared to concrete pavements, Cement Treated Base is an affordable and time-saving solution for a variety of construction projects that rely on evenly distributed load-bearing platforms to remove sub-grade fatigue. What’s more, it has been demonstrated that Cement Treated BaseCEMENT TREATED BASE service in texas exceeds the structural proprieties of a thicker crushed aggregate base, making it a standard choice for modern road construction.

    ReplyDelete
  35. A natural aphrodisiac turkish epimedium dubai that gives you energy and relief from erectile dysfunction and enhances both female arousal and male performance

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hasten is uniquely positioned to maximize the success of its customers by utilizing its vast network of relationships along with its unwavering focus on its core principles of honesty, reliability, quality, credibility, and trust. With the goal of providing quality products, safely, and on a timely basis, Hasten will ensure you are satisfied with the end result.
    Fly Ash Texas

    ReplyDelete
  37. Being the best backsplash contractor Edmonton, we are passionate about backsplashes for kitchens or baths for homes and commercial projects. Our creative staff will help you choose the best tile pairing for your new project or renovation task. Our wall tiles installation Edmonton is flawless, and we perform ceiling ceramic tile installation as well. We are unmatched in service, selection, and styles as backsplash installers Edmonton. Whether your design idea is contemporary, formal, farmhouse, or even eclectic, we can install it to fit your budgeted plans for your backsplash Edmonton. Our goal at wall tiles contractor Edmonton is to deliver you endless inspiration for your project and and we will exceed your expectations. Select from a wide selection of wall covering tiles for your backsplash installation Edmonton or ceiling tile installation.
    Backsplash Contractor Edmonton

    ReplyDelete